The United Federation of Teachers (UFT), one of New York City’s most influential unions, has officially voiced its opposition to a proposed casino in Times Square. The plan, spearheaded by Caesars Entertainment, SL Green, and Jay-Z’s Roc Nation, aims to establish a casino at 1515 Broadway, the same location as the Minskoff Theatre, home to Disney’s The Lion King. However, UFT President Michael Mulgrew argues the casino would harm the cultural and educational significance of the Broadway theater district.

Mulgrew emphasized the importance of Broadway as an educational resource for New York City students, particularly through initiatives such as the Broadway League’s Broadway Bridges program, which offers every public school 10th grader the opportunity to attend a theater performance before graduation. He described Broadway as “an educational goldmine for the children of our city” and stressed the need to protect this cultural institution.

Citing personal experience, Mulgrew recalled chaperoning students to Broadway performances, many of whom had never experienced live theater before. The theater district’s proximity to six public schools, including P.S. 212 Midtown West and the Professional Performing Arts High School, underscores its critical role in enriching the education of local youth.

“Broadway offers unique educational and career opportunities for our students,” Mulgrew stated according to New York Post. “A casino would undermine the Theater District and dilute the distinctive power of Broadway.”

Coalition Gains Momentum Against Casino Proposal

The UFT’s stance aligns with the No Times Square Casino Coalition, a group of over 30 organizations, including the Broadway League, representing theater owners, producers, and operators. The coalition argues that Times Square, already a global tourist destination and economic driver for the city, does not need a casino.

Mulgrew acknowledged the potential economic benefits of a casino elsewhere in New York City, stating, “Put the casino somewhere else!” He clarified that the UFT does not oppose casino developments entirely but believes Times Square is an inappropriate location given its cultural significance.

Response from Caesars Entertainment

Representatives from Caesars Palace Times Square countered the UFT’s concerns, asserting that the proposed casino would complement the Broadway theater district rather than harm it.

“The UFT didn’t do its homework on our project,” a spokesperson said in a statement. The casino’s backers argue that their plan would actually increase Broadway’s audience and include commitments to educational programs, such as providing tens of millions of dollars in Broadway tickets for New York City students.

Broadway unions representing actors and musicians have expressed support for the casino proposal, claiming it would bring financial benefits to the theater community and boost tourism in Times Square.

Competition for Downstate Casino Licenses

The Times Square casino bid is one of several high-profile proposals competing for up to three downstate casino licenses that the New York State Gaming Commission is expected to approve by the end of 2025. Each successful bid will provide a minimum of $500 million in upfront fees, with proceeds directed to the Metropolitan Transportation Authority.

Other contenders include:

  • Wynn/Related Companies’ $12 billion gaming complex at Hudson Yards.
  • Steve Cohen’s $8 billion entertainment complex near Citi Field in Queens.
  • Las Vegas Sands’ plan to transform the Nassau Veterans Memorial Coliseum into a casino.
  • A $3 billion project near the Coney Island boardwalk.
  • Bally’s proposal for a gaming facility near the Ferry Point golf course in the Bronx.