Brazilian lawmakers are considering a proposal that could require online betting operators to reimburse customers for losses incurred under the country’s recently suspended Bets regime. The bill, introduced by federal deputy Ricardo Abrão, would establish a legal framework for calculating refunds and impose additional obligations on operators regarding customer balances and transaction records.

Bill No. 5,502/2026, titled the Full Restitution and Compensation for Bettors Law, was submitted to the Chamber of Deputies by Abrão, who represents the Brazilian state of Rio de Janeiro for the Brazilian Social Democracy Party (PSDB-RJ). On 12 November, the proposal was forwarded to the Consumer Protection Committee (CDC) and the Constitution, Justice and Citizenship Committee (CCJC) for examination.

The initiative has already attracted criticism from legal professionals, particularly over its intention to include legitimate gambling losses among the amounts operators would have to return. Udo Seckelmann, lawyer and partner at Bichara e Motta Advogados, described the proposal as “a genuine legal aberration”, arguing that it could impose substantial liabilities on companies for transactions conducted under legally established betting arrangements.

The bill comes amid continued uncertainty surrounding Brazil’s online gambling market following President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva‘s decision to suspend betting operations through Provisional Measure No. 1,394/2026.

Proposed legislation sets out extensive refund obligations

Abrão’s proposal seeks to establish rules governing the reimbursement of money lost through online betting platforms operating under the suspended regulatory framework. Its central provision concerns the calculation of bettors’ net losses, with operators required to provide customers with free, detailed transaction statements within 10 working days.

The legislation identifies 10 circumstances in which companies would have to return funds. These include customers’ total net losses recorded in their accounts, outstanding balances that operators have failed to release and winnings that remain unpaid.

The proposed reimbursement framework also covers cancelled bets and financial transactions conducted without the account holder’s authorization. Additional circumstances outlined in the Brazilian-language version of the bill include duplicate charges, unjustified withholding of withdrawals or prizes, and the use of customer funds after an operator’s authorization has been suspended.

Operators could also face repayment obligations involving wagers placed by individuals subject to blocking or self-exclusion measures. Fraud, technical failures and periods when betting platforms become unavailable are among the other situations addressed by the legislation.

Through these provisions, Abrão intends to establish a mechanism for determining the amounts owed to customers following the interruption of the country’s betting market. The deputy has argued that companies and their controlling shareholders should bear the financial responsibility associated with the proposed reimbursements.

His justification refers to the rapid expansion of online gambling in Brazil and the subsequent suspension of the industry. Abrão maintains that the disruption has created an urgent need for measures addressing customers’ outstanding funds and potential compensation claims.

The lawmaker has also sought to secure backing from political groups in Congress, describing the proposed repayments as a response to the consequences of the betting market’s expansion. He argued that the industry had participated in the “unchecked expansion of a market that has harmed vulnerable Brazilians, making repayment of customers’ losses necessary.”

Abrão further maintains that the financial burden should remain with betting companies and their controlling shareholders, avoiding any transfer of reimbursement costs to public funds.

Legal expert warns of potentially devastating consequences

The inclusion of ordinary betting losses in the proposed refund arrangements has become the main point of contention among legal professionals. Seckelmann told SBC Notícias Brasil that the legislation could fundamentally alter the legal principles governing betting contracts by making operators responsible for returning money customers had legitimately lost.

“In practice, it seeks to force operators to return money lost by bettors through lawfully placed bets, as though the activity did not, by its very nature, involve risks and the possibility of losses,” Seckelmann said. “Holding companies accountable for fraud, operational failures or breaches of contract is one thing; turning legitimate losses into an obligation to reimburse is something entirely different. The proposal subverts the legal rationale underpinning betting, undermines legal certainty and disregards the inherently uncertain nature of betting contracts.”

The lawyer also questioned whether operators could realistically meet the financial and administrative requirements established by the bill. “Financially, operators could be required to reimburse billions of reais in losses accumulated by bettors, creating an unpredictable and potentially unpayable liability,” he said. “Operationally, the obligation to reconstruct individual transaction histories for millions of users within an extremely short time frame is practically impossible to fulfil.”

He added that the legislation could substantially increase the financial exposure of both betting companies and their directors, affecting the sector’s economic viability and the ability of businesses to assess their potential liabilities.

Constitutional challenges could follow congressional approval

Although the proposal could attract political support given the pressure currently facing Brazil’s betting industry, Seckelmann expects it to encounter significant legal resistance. He identified several constitutional principles that could become central to challenges against the legislation, including legal certainty, proportionality, freedom of enterprise and the protection of validly completed legal acts.

Asked whether the bill could advance through Congress, the lawyer acknowledged the political circumstances surrounding its introduction while questioning its legal foundations. “Politically, the bill could find support given the current climate of pressure against the betting sector. However, consumer protection cannot serve as justification for creating arbitrary financial obligations or disregarding the nature of lawfully concluded contracts. If approved in its current form, the bill will certainly be challenged in court.”

The legislative debate is unfolding alongside a separate legal and political dispute over the future of online gambling in Brazil. Following Lula’s 25 September 2026 decision to suspend betting activities, Justice Luiz Fux of the Supreme Federal Court (STF) ordered the suspension of lower-court proceedings challenging the ban.

The Supreme Court is expected to determine whether the presidential measure is constitutional. Congress must separately decide whether to convert the suspension into federal legislation. Abrão has cited the presidential measure as part of the justification for introducing his reimbursement proposal, arguing that the interruption of betting operations makes a dedicated consumer compensation framework necessary.

Sponsored

Featured casino offer

A casino offer for players in your country, from the World Casino Directory listings.

18+ · T&Cs apply · Please gamble responsibly