FanDuel identified suspicious betting activity involving Cleveland Guardians pitcher Luis Ortiz shortly before Major League Baseball placed him on administrative leave, according to testimony presented during the federal trial involving Ortiz and teammate Emmanuel Clase. Prosecutors also introduced messages showing Clase allegedly instructed an associate to transfer part of his betting winnings to the Dominican Republic.

Josh Mehta, FanDuel’s director of legal and regulatory affairs, testified on Monday that betting activity involving a specific Ortiz pitch in June 2025 prompted the sportsbook to suspend several customer accounts. His testimony provided the first direct indication of how the investigation into the alleged pitch-manipulation scheme initially attracted attention from a betting operator.

According to Mehta, six wagers were placed on the first pitch of the third inning during a June 27, 2025, game against the St. Louis Cardinals. The pitch, a low-and-away slider thrown to catcher Pedro Pages, resulted in bettors winning more than $19,000 after wagering that it would be called a ball.

FanDuel suspended four accounts connected to those wagers the following day. The same accounts had also placed bets on another Ortiz pitch from June 15, 2025. Ortiz was subsequently placed on administrative leave on July 3, while Clase received the same designation on July 28.

According to The Athletic, Mehta said he could not identify the precise reason the wagers attracted attention, explaining that FanDuel generally suspends accounts when customers breach its terms of use. He confirmed that using insider information to place bets constitutes a violation of those rules. Defense attorneys were scheduled to cross-examine him on Tuesday.

The testimony forms part of proceedings in the US District Court for the Eastern District of New York, where Ortiz and Clase face four federal charges each. Both players have pleaded not guilty and deny the allegations.

Prosecutors Present Evidence of Betting Proceeds and Transfers

The prosecution’s case also focused on alleged financial arrangements between Clase and individuals who placed wagers on his pitches.

On Tuesday, prosecutors presented screenshots of a conversation between Clase and bettor Enoc Pena concerning winnings from an April 12, 2025, game against the Kansas City Royals. Pena had reportedly earned $9,890 after betting on a pitch Clase threw to Royals star Bobby Witt Jr.

FBI special agent Noah Bilger testified that betting records confirmed Pena’s winnings. The following day, Clase contacted him to discuss the result.

According to the messages presented in court, Clase asked, “Did you find something to play?”

Pena replied, “Yes, he killed it,” followed by “$9900.”

Clase then instructed him, “Send some of that to the DR for me,” before asking that the money be transferred under another person’s name. He also referred to repairs at a “country house” as the stated purpose for the payment.

The exchange was presented as evidence of an alleged arrangement through which Clase sought to receive money connected to successful bets. Prosecutors have alleged that Pena acted as an intermediary between the pitcher and a group of bettors who wagered on more than 100 pitches over three seasons, generating at least $400,000 in winnings.

Earlier testimony from cooperating prosecution witness Jenner Olivo also addressed transfers to the Dominican Republic. Olivo said Pena instructed him to send money to an individual whose surname appeared as Clase in WhatsApp messages.

However, prosecutors identified the recipient as Luis Gabriel Vargas Martinez, rather than the pitcher. The individual appeared in Pena’s phone under the name Luis Martinez Clase. Olivo testified that he sent three payments totaling $5,500 in April 2025, although he said he did not personally know the recipient.

The prosecution also examined messages containing references to “chicken” and “rooster,” which investigators believe were coded instructions concerning pitches targeted by bettors.

One exchange dated September 30, 2023, included a message from Clase to Pena stating: “It’s chicken number three. After killing the first two, play number three. And if I can’t kill him, don’t play. I have to kill the first two.”

Prosecutors subsequently presented additional messages in which Pena discussed the information with bettors. Olivo explained how the instructions were communicated to the group, including a message directing them to wager on the first pitch to the third batter. Clase ultimately did not pitch in that game.

Defense attorneys disputed the prosecution’s interpretation. Clase’s lawyer, Michael Ferrara, argued that the references could relate to cockfighting, noting that Pena owns roosters and participates in cockfighting gambling in the Dominican Republic.

Ferrara also questioned whether Olivo’s testimony reliably connected Clase to the betting activity. He established that Olivo had never communicated directly with Clase about wagers and highlighted examples of losing bets. The defense further argued that bettors could have anticipated certain pitch selections by examining Clase’s previous performances against the same batters.

Ortiz’s attorney, Elizabeth Geddes, challenged Olivo over his involvement in separate alleged schemes involving Pena and another individual identified as El Vale. Those activities concerned fraudulent bank loans and debit cards, which the defense suggested could provide alternative explanations for some financial transfers.

During his testimony, Olivo described Pena as “a person that gambles constantly,” while acknowledging the latter’s involvement in other gambling activities.

Vasquez’s attorney, Todd Spodek, also questioned Olivo about his client’s alleged involvement. Olivo maintained that Robinson Vasquez had no connection to the pitch-rigging scheme and said he had already communicated that position to prosecutors.

Vasquez previously lived with Olivo while the two worked as laborers on Nantucket, Massachusetts. He operated a community savings arrangement known as a “san,” a system popular in the Dominican Republic. His defense has argued that certain payments attributed to the alleged conspiracy were actually connected to this arrangement.

Spodek said he intended to seek an acquittal after prosecutors concluded their presentation, arguing that the government had failed to establish sufficient evidence against his client.

Million-Dollar Loans and Wider Betting Investigations

Financial arrangements involving the two Guardians pitchers also featured in Tuesday’s proceedings. Jared Friedberg, general counsel at RockFence Capital, testified about loans his company had extended to Clase and Ortiz.

Friedberg said Clase borrowed approximately $5.7 million during his major league career, which began in 2019. Ortiz received another $1.7 million in loans from the company, which specializes in financing professional baseball players.

Friedberg said RockFence had no particular concerns about either player’s financial position before the gambling investigation became public. The company became concerned about the loans after MLB placed both pitchers on paid leave during the summer of 2025.

The prosecution alleges that Clase manipulated 18 pitches across three seasons, while Ortiz is accused of rigging two. Both players face charges of wire fraud conspiracy, honest services wire fraud conspiracy, conspiracy to influence sports contests by bribery and money laundering conspiracy. A third defendant, Robinson Vasquez, faces a wire fraud conspiracy charge.

The government has indicated that it expects to finish presenting its case by Friday, although proceedings could continue into the following week. A separate appeals court ruling expected on Tuesday concerns whether prosecutors can introduce text messages exchanged between Ortiz and his spouse. The contents of those messages have not been disclosed.

The trial also comes amid other federal prosecutions involving alleged manipulation of sporting events for betting purposes.

Former University at Buffalo forward Isaiah Adams received a six-month prison sentence and 15 months of supervised release for his involvement in an NCAA basketball point-shaving operation. Former University of New Orleans guard Dyquavion “Jah” Short received one day in prison and two years of supervised release in a related case.

The wider investigation involved 17 college basketball teams and 39 players accused of altering their performances to benefit bettors. Prosecutors identified 27 defendants, with 24 having pleaded guilty or planning to do so.

Sponsored

Featured casino offer

A casino offer for players in your country, from the World Casino Directory listings.

18+ · T&Cs apply · Please gamble responsibly