President Donald Trump’s two nominees for the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) faced sustained questioning from senators over prediction markets and the legal status of sports event contracts.
Democratic nominee Matthew Rowland and Republican nominee Nathan Anonick appeared before the Senate Agriculture Committee on Tuesday, November 17. Neither gave a definitive answer on whether a contract tied to the outcome of a sporting event should be treated as sports betting.
If confirmed, they would join CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, currently the commission’s only member. Rowland has been nominated to serve the remainder of a term ending April 13, 2028, while Anonick’s proposed term runs through June 19, 2031.
The committee took no vote during the hearing. Chairman John Boozman said “the record will remain open for two business days,” while Sen. Ben Ray Luján indicated that both nominees are expected to win confirmation.
Senators Challenge CFTC’s Position on Sports Contracts
Sen. Tina Smith focused on the dispute between the federal regulator and states that consider sports event contracts a form of gambling.
Minnesota passed a prediction market ban in May, although a federal court later temporarily blocked it. The CFTC has challenged Minnesota’s law as part of a wider legal fight over whether states can regulate contracts offered through federally supervised exchanges.
Smith pointed to the 2018 Supreme Court decision in Murphy v. NCAA, which restored states’ authority to legalize sports betting, and to the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, which governs tribal gaming.
Rowland agreed with Smith’s interpretation of Murphy. Anonick said that was also his understanding, while adding that he was “not an expert on that case, but I believe so.”
Smith then asked whether there was any practical distinction between a sportsbook wager and a sports event contract.
“It seems to me that if it walks like a bet and quacks like a bet, it in in fact a bet,” the senator said.
Rowland noted that courts have reached different conclusions and said active litigation limited how far he could go.
“It’s hard for me to comment on active litigation that the CFTC is engaged in, but I’m certainly very sympathetic to the concerns that the states and tribes have raised and would kind of want to work with them further, if I was confirmed, on that.”
Anonick also declined to take a firm position.
“So from a legal perspective, I wouldn’t want to tip the scales on that, but I appreciate your practical examples and I agree with my friend Matt, in that I’ve heard from the tribes as well,” Anonick said. “It’s a very charged emotional issue and I appreciate how sensitive it is.”
Smith responded:
“I don’t think that this is an emotional issue. I think this is a legal issue. I think it is a core legal tenet that is laid out in the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, as well as the rights of states to regulate sports betting.”
Nominees Point to Courts and Public Interest Review
The hearing also examined how the CFTC should treat event contracts under federal law while litigation continues.
Anonick was asked directly whether a contract on an NFL game result should count as sports betting.
“I do think that question, from a legal perspective, is complex,” Anonick said.
He later added:
“I appreciate the practical argument,” he said. “I just say it’s legally complex.”
Anonick said he would not form a final view before consulting legal counsel, states and tribes.
“I do not have a preconceived position because it would be irresponsible without going through that process,”
Rowland focused more heavily on the CFTC’s obligation to consider the public interest.
“I do think that the framework that’s set out in the special rule in the Section 5CC, 5C really does direct the agency to think about the public interest,” Rowland said. “I know the commission under chair Selig has undertaken a rulemaking on this issue.”
He added that regulators should “think long and hard about balancing the public interest against the kind of economic usefulness of these contracts.”
The CFTC published a proposed rule on October 9 that would explicitly define event contracts involving areas such as sports or politics as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act.
Both nominees said they would follow any eventual Supreme Court decision on the jurisdictional dispute.
“I also think there is likely to be a (U.S.) Supreme Court decision within the next term or the one after, and, of course, we would be bound the court’s decision on that,” Rowland said.
Staffing and Enforcement Also Come Under Review
Sen. Adam Schiff used the hearing to criticize Selig’s handling of prediction markets, referring to his earlier confirmation testimony and subsequent position on litigation involving state restrictions.
“I don’t know that I’ve ever been so blatantly deceived by a nominee before,” Schiff said, as reported by SBC Americas.
Sen. Raphael Warnock raised separate concerns about enforcement and political influence. He asked whether a company’s ties to Trump or his family should affect its treatment by the CFTC.
Rowland replied:
“I think that the law needs to be enforced fairly without fear or favor, and so the answer is no.”
Anonick said:
“I’d agree that I think the law should apply equally and fairly to everyone. It should not matter who is involved.”
Lawmakers also questioned the agency’s reduced staffing levels. The CFTC has lost about a quarter of its previous workforce while taking on broader responsibilities involving prediction markets and cryptocurrency.
Both nominees indicated they would consider increasing staff where needed.
Anonick said that “a full commission is the best approach to sound, durable policy.”
If the Senate confirms both candidates, the CFTC would have three commissioners, leaving two seats vacant as legal disputes over sports event contracts continue.
